Transforming the World by the True Word

This week, finding myself hungry to read something that would stimulate my mind and spirit, I pulled Pedagogy of the Oppressed by Paulo Freire off the shelf.

In grad school, I had this book as required reading for a comparative education class. But one seldom has time to give readings the slow, close read they deserve in grad school. Paulo Friere is a writer whose every sentence is so packed with meaning it demands reflection and meditation. We spent only one or two classes discussing him, but I felt like I could have spent an entire semester discussing nothing but Freire’s ideas.

Central to Freire’s educational theory was the role of dialogue in the educational process.  Education that transforms, Freire believed, could not be a one-sided impartation of information from the superior to the inferior. Rather the teacher must approach as a learner, and the student must also become a teacher. For this interaction to take place dialogue is essential.  This dialogue, if genuine (and only if genuine), would have a humanizing effect on both the teacher-student and the student-teacher.  He wrote:

As we attempt to analyze dialogue as a human phenomenon, we discover something which is the essence of dialogue itself: the word. But the word is more than just an instrument which makes dialogue possible; accordingly, we must seek its constitutive elements. Within the word we find two dimensions, reflection and action, in such radical interaction that if one is sacrificed – even in part – the other immediately suffers. There is no true word that is not at the same time a praxis. Thus to speak a true word is to transform the world.

By contrast “an unauthentic word” is one that that neglects either reflection or action, thus is “one which is unable to transform reality.”  “Human existence,” Freire declares, “cannot be silent.”  And to attempt to silence another is, in fact, “dehumanizing aggression.”  Therefore it is only in genuine dialogue, where one both speaks and listens, hears and is heard, that transformation occurs.  These thoughts have profound implications on how we teach, not only in our schools, but in our communities of faith, in our homes, and in our charities and other social service organizations.

What is necessary for this dialogue to occur?  Freire points to five elements: profound love, humility, intense faith, mutual trust, and hope.  Without these dialogue cannot occur.  But these deserve their own full attention at another time.

Author’s note: Speaking of dialogue, my blog posts usually flow out of dialogue.  This one was inspired not only by picking up Freire this week, but also by conversations with my husband as I read him quotes, and exchanges with my fellow blogger Peter here and here.


Living Hope

This is a flower on my Easter Cactus. The plant it grew on has a special story behind it.

Years ago, I got a clipping from someone. I rooted it, and then planted it. But then for a long, long time nothing happened. The branches of the plant were a dull green, and semi-wilted. They neither thrived nor died.

One day about 20 years ago, as my life was quietly shattering all around me, I sat in my living room and looked at that plant. It seemed so pitiful. Perhaps I identified with it, feeling neither alive nor dead. Quietly, I let out a prayer: “If You can make that plant live, perhaps I could have hope again.”

Not long after, I glanced over at the plant one day, and the branch was spouting another leaf! Soon the little transplanted clipping began to grow. And grow and grow and grow. And then surprisingly one spring I looked at it and it had budded, and the buds opened into flowers.

The plant has now been budding and flowering every year for the past 15 years at least. I call it the hope plant. This picture is of its most recent flowering. The flowers are very small and I wanted to capture their delicacy up close. I took a number of pictures of these flowers but this one came out especially nice because of the dark background.